The bill directs the Secretary of the Treasury to mint commemorative $5 gold and $1 silver coins marking the 25th anniversary of the September 11, 2001 attacks and to transfer surcharges from coin sales to the National September 11 Memorial and Museum (NS11M) to support its operations and maintenance. It sets mintage limits, metal content and sizing, quality (proof and uncirculated), and requires design consultation with the Museum and the Commission of Fine Arts and review by the Citizens Coinage Advisory Committee.
Operationally the statute requires the Treasury to set sale prices that recover design and issuance costs (including marketing and shipping), to collect a $35 surcharge for each gold coin and $10 for each silver coin, and to withhold surcharge disbursements until the United States recovers the full cost of minting and issuing the program. The bill also limits issuance to a one-year window beginning January 1, 2027, subjects the Museum to audit rules, and instructs Treasury to ensure no net cost to the federal government.
At a Glance
What It Does
Authorizes up to two minted commemorative coin types—a $5 gold and a $1 silver—sets mintage caps and metal specifications, requires surcharges on every sale to fund the National September 11 Memorial and Museum, and conditions disbursement on Treasury recovering minting costs.
Who It Affects
The United States Mint (including production and marketing teams), the National September 11 Memorial and Museum (as the surcharge recipient and audit subject), coin collectors and dealers, and advisory bodies (Commission of Fine Arts; Citizens Coinage Advisory Committee).
Why It Matters
The bill uses a standard numismatic vehicle to raise discretionary funding for a national memorial while preserving federal cost-recovery protections; it therefore creates operational requirements for Treasury and the Museum and a limited new product for the numismatic market.
More articles like this one.
A weekly email with all the latest developments on this topic.
What This Bill Actually Does
The statute creates a tightly defined commemorative coin program: two denominations with concrete mintage caps and specified metal content and dimensions, issued only in proof and uncirculated qualities. The Secretary must price coins to include face value, a statutory surcharge, and all design and issuance costs; prepaid and bulk orders are permitted with reasonable discounts.
The one‑year issuance window channels sales to a discrete campaign rather than an open-ended fundraising effort.
Design work is procedural and collaborative. The Secretary must consult the National September 11 Memorial and Museum and the Commission of Fine Arts when selecting artwork and submit designs for review to the Citizens Coinage Advisory Committee.
The law requires specific inscriptions—Liberty, In God We Trust, United States of America, E Pluribus Unum, and a 25th Anniversary mark—and mandates that at least one coin bear the inscription "Never Forget." This binds the aesthetic and messaging floor for the program while leaving selection authority with the Secretary.Financial controls are explicit. The coins are treated as numismatic items for statutory purposes; surcharges collected for the Memorial are paid promptly but only after the Treasury verifies that minting and issuance costs have been recovered.
The National September 11 Memorial and Museum must submit to the statutorily referenced audit regime for surcharge funds. Finally, the bill signals—nonbindingly—a preference for striking the coins at the West Point Mint and imposes a statutory check on timing by deferring all coin issuance to a single calendar window beginning January 1, 2027.
The Five Things You Need to Know
Mintage limits: up to 50,000 $5 gold coins and up to 400,000 $1 silver coins; gold coins must contain at least 90% gold and weigh 8.359 grams; silver coins must contain at least 90% silver and weigh 26.73 grams.
Surcharges: $35 added to each $5 gold coin and $10 added to each $1 silver coin; surcharges are earmarked for the National September 11 Memorial and Museum.
Issuance window: the Secretary may issue these coins only during the one‑year period beginning January 1, 2027.
Cost recovery rule: the Treasury must recover the total cost of designing and issuing the coins (labor, materials, dies, machinery, overhead, marketing, shipping) before any surcharge funds are disbursed to the Museum.
Design and oversight: designs must include specified inscriptions, at least one coin must say 'Never Forget', the Secretary must consult the Museum and the Commission of Fine Arts, and the Citizens Coinage Advisory Committee must review designs.
Section-by-Section Breakdown
Every bill we cover gets an analysis of its key sections.
Short title
Provides the act's name: "25th Anniversary of 9/11 Commemorative Coin Act." This is the identifying label used in subsequent statutory and administrative references.
Findings
Sets out the legislative findings describing the human and historic context for the memorial and museum. While not operative, these findings anchor the program's purpose and justify directing surcharge proceeds to the National September 11 Memorial and Museum.
Coin specifications and numismatic treatment
Prescribes denominations, precise weights, diameters, metal minimums, and hard caps on mintage for each coin type and states the coins are legal tender and statutorily 'numismatic items.' Treating them as numismatic items triggers the application of the commemorative-coin provisions in title 31 and the companion accounting and audit rules that follow.
Design requirements, selection, and review
Requires inscriptions and a thematic mandate—emblematic of courage, sacrifice, resilience—and mandates at least one coin carry the phrase 'Never Forget.' It vests design selection authority in the Secretary but conditions that authority on consultation with the Museum and the Commission of Fine Arts and review by the Citizens Coinage Advisory Committee, creating a multi‑stakeholder approval pathway that can lengthen design timelines.
Issuance quality, preferred mint location, and timing
Requires proof and uncirculated strikes and includes a nonbinding 'sense of Congress' that the coins should be struck at West Point where feasible. Critically, it limits the Secretary's authority to issue the coins to a single one‑year period starting January 1, 2027—a scheduling constraint that concentrates production and sales.
Sales, surcharges, audit, and financial safeguards
Sets the pricing formula (face value + surcharge + full cost of design/issuance), authorizes reasonable discounts for bulk and prepaid orders, requires the Secretary to ensure no net cost to the federal government, and directs prompt payment of surcharges to the Museum only after cost recovery. The Museum is subject to statutory audit requirements for surcharge receipts, and the Secretary must respect the annual statutory limit on commemorative coin programs when issuing these coins.
This bill is one of many.
Codify tracks hundreds of bills on Finance across all five countries.
Explore Finance in Codify Search →Who Benefits and Who Bears the Cost
Every bill creates winners and losers. Here's who stands to gain and who bears the cost.
Who Benefits
- National September 11 Memorial and Museum — gains a dedicated surcharge revenue stream to support operations, maintenance, and programming, subject to audit and cost‑recovery timing.
- Victims' families, survivors, and first responders — indirect beneficiaries through museum-funded services, educational programs, and continued maintenance of the memorial.
- Coin collectors and numismatic community — receive limited‑mintage, themed proof and uncirculated coins that may have collector appeal and secondary‑market value.
- United States Mint (product lines and sales teams) — benefits from a new controlled product line, revenue for numismatic programs, and utilization of mint capacity.
- Artists and sculptors involved in design competitions — opportunity to contribute to a high‑profile national commemorative program and receive professional recognition.
Who Bears the Cost
- Collectors and buyers — pay the surcharge (and market price reflecting metal and production costs); their demand ultimately determines net funds raised for the Museum.
- United States Mint/Treasury — must front design and production costs and manage marketing, order fulfillment, and compliance, though statutory cost‑recovery aims to prevent net federal expense.
- National September 11 Memorial and Museum — must comply with audit requirements, manage receipt and reporting of surcharge funds, and may face cash‑flow timing constraints until Treasury verifies cost recovery.
- Other commemorative coin programs — the congressional cap on commemorative programs per year may force scheduling tradeoffs if multiple programs plan issuance in 2027.
- Coin dealers and retail distributors — face inventory and pricing risk if demand for the program underperforms or metal‑price volatility affects secondary pricing.
Key Issues
The Core Tension
The bill pits two legitimate aims against each other: raising dedicated funds for a national memorial and protecting the federal fisc from subsidizing a commemorative program. Ensuring full cost recovery protects taxpayers but may delay or reduce the net funds available to the Museum; loosening cost controls would speed funding but shift financial risk to the government.
The bill combines a traditional numismatic funding mechanism with strict fiscal safeguards; those same safeguards create practical tensions. Conditioning surcharge disbursement on full Treasury cost recovery protects taxpayers but can delay funds flowing to the Museum, creating potential cash‑flow mismatches between the Museum's operational needs and revenue timing.
That delay will matter most if sales are front‑loaded or if production/marketing costs exceed conservative estimates.
Market risk is real. The statutory mintage caps and surcharge levels set revenue potential but do not guarantee sales; low collector demand would leave most value tied up in coins rather than in surcharge proceeds.
Conversely, unexpectedly strong demand raises manufacturing and fulfillment pressures and could require more intensive inventory controls and customer service. The annual two‑program commemorative cap in title 31 adds scheduling risk: if two other programs occupy the same calendar year, Treasury must either refuse issuance or reassign timing, and the bill permits Treasury guidance but not an automatic exemption.
Implementation details are unresolved in the text. The "sense of Congress" favoring West Point is nonbinding and may not withstand production scheduling or capacity constraints.
The design consultation requirements create potential for disagreement between advisory bodies and the Secretary about imagery and inscriptions, especially given the subject's sensitivity; the statute sets content floor—what must appear—but leaves final selection timing to administrative processes that can be lengthy. Finally, metal price volatility and the mechanics of prepaid/bulk discounts will affect the Treasury's ability to precisely calculate sale prices that both attract buyers and meet cost‑recovery obligations.
Try it yourself.
Ask a question in plain English, or pick a topic below. Results in seconds.