The GREEN Appraisals Act requires creditors and the federal housing agencies (FHA, FHFA as it oversees the enterprises, Ginnie Mae, USDA Rural Housing Service, and VA) to integrate homeowner energy reports into the residential appraisal and underwriting process. The bill mandates a borrower disclosure, gives borrowers the right to request and receive portable copies of energy reports, requires appraisers to take such reports into account, and bars using the presence of an energy report as a reason to reject an appraisal or loan application.
The Act also sets minimum definitions and quality standards for energy reports (including HERS and DOE Home Energy Score as approved methods), requires a 7‑hour AQB‑approved continuing education course for “qualified appraisers,” and directs agency guidance, an advisory committee of stakeholders, and lender system changes within a two‑year implementation window. For lenders, appraisers, and policymakers this shifts how energy-related features are treated in valuation, underwriting, and loan origination systems—potentially changing market signals for energy upgrades while imposing new compliance and technical requirements.
At a Glance
What It Does
The bill requires creditors to give prospective borrowers a written disclosure about energy reports at the same time as routine TILA disclosures, to permit borrowers to provide an energy report to appraisers, and to supply the appraiser with the report on assignment (with borrower consent). It requires qualified appraisers to consider energy reports when developing an appraisal and prohibits using the consideration of an energy report to reject an appraisal or loan.
Who It Affects
Covered agencies (FHA, FHFA for the enterprises, Ginnie Mae, USDA Rural Housing Service, VA), creditors for residential mortgage loans intended for sale, insurance, guarantee, or securitization by those agencies, licensed appraisers, energy raters (HERS, Home Energy Score), and homeowners seeking covered loans.
Why It Matters
The Act embeds energy characteristics into the valuation and underwriting ecosystem rather than leaving them as informal disclosures, which can change the market signal for energy upgrades and affect underwriting outcomes. It also forces operational changes: disclosure timing, appraiser training, new data flows to appraisers, and lender system updates that score and accommodate appraisals that consider energy reports.
More articles like this one.
A weekly email with all the latest developments on this topic.
What This Bill Actually Does
The GREEN Appraisals Act creates a framework so energy-related home information can be formally considered during residential mortgage appraisals and underwriting. It applies to residential mortgage loans that are made, insured, purchased, guaranteed, or securitized by specified federal housing agencies.
At the point a lender issues the standard TILA/RESPA disclosures, the lender must also give the borrower a written notice explaining that the borrower can obtain and submit an energy report and that appraisers will consider that information—though consideration might raise, lower, or not change the appraised value.
On underwriting, creditors must use the appraised value produced by a qualified appraiser, and the bill expressly says that the mere presence of an energy report (or the appraiser’s taking it into account) cannot be a lawful basis to reject an appraisal or loan application. Starting March 1, 2026, if an energy report exists and the borrower consents, the creditor must give that report to the assigned appraiser and ensure its origination and underwriting systems can accommodate appraisals that take the report into account.The Act defines what counts as an energy report: an analysis that documents energy features, estimates energy costs or savings, and can estimate on‑site renewable generation.
It lists acceptable methods—HERS by RESNET‑certified raters, DOE Home Energy Score, or other Secretary‑approved methods with QA procedures. The bill also creates the “qualified appraiser” standard: a state‑licensed appraiser who has completed at least seven hours of AQB‑approved continuing education on considering energy reports (including case studies and an exam) and is competent for the assignment.To operationalize these requirements the covered agencies must jointly issue creditor guidance, accept applicable valuation approaches that demonstrate market reaction to energy features, stand up an advisory committee of stakeholders (lenders, appraisers, energy raters, builders, consumer advocates, etc.), and require lenders to update origination and underwriting systems within two years of enactment so appraisals that consider energy reports are reviewed and scored consistently.
The bill leaves appraisal judgment intact—guidance cannot dictate how appraisers must weigh the report—while setting shared process and data expectations.
The Five Things You Need to Know
The bill requires creditors to deliver a written disclosure to borrowers about energy reports on the same date they provide the TILA disclosure referenced in 12 C.F.R. 1026.19(e)(1)(iii)(A).
It prohibits using an appraiser’s consideration of an energy report as a basis to reject a home appraisal or block a covered loan application.
Starting March 1, 2026, creditors must provide an existing energy report to the assigned appraiser (with borrower consent) and ensure origination/underwriting systems can accommodate appraisals that consider those reports.
An ‘energy report’ must detail home energy features and estimate energy costs/savings or on‑site renewable generation, and may be produced via HERS (RESNET), DOE Home Energy Score, or other Secretary‑approved methods with quality assurance.
A ‘qualified appraiser’ must hold state licensure, be competent for the assignment, and complete at least 7 hours of Appraisal Foundation (AQB)‑approved continuing education on using energy reports, including case studies and an exam.
Section-by-Section Breakdown
Every bill we cover gets an analysis of its key sections.
Short title
Names the measure the Getting Renewable and Energy Efficient Neighborhoods Appraisals Act of 2025 (GREEN Appraisals Act of 2025). This is purely stylistic but signals the bill’s dual consumer and climate framing.
Mandatory borrower disclosure timed with TILA disclosure
The bill directs heads of covered agencies to require creditors to give a written disclosure to prospective borrowers the same day they provide the cited TILA disclosure. The disclosure must explain the borrower’s right to obtain an energy report, the option to provide it to the creditor or appraiser, and that an appraiser will take the report into consideration while still retaining the possibility of a higher, lower, or unchanged value. Practically, creditors will need to insert this language into early loan scripting and borrower packets and train originators to capture borrower consent for sharing reports.
Use appraised value; don’t reject loans because of energy reports
Creditors must use the appraiser’s appraised value for underwriting, and agencies must prohibit using the consideration of an energy report as a reason to deny an appraisal or loan application. This creates a legal firewall against lenders or secondary market actors excluding loans simply because an appraiser considered energy characteristics—protecting borrowers from procedural rejections tied solely to energy data. Lenders will still underwrite to the appraised value and all existing underwriting requirements remain in force.
Deliver report to appraiser on assignment; borrower copy at no cost
On and after March 1, 2026, if an energy report exists and the borrower consents, creditors must provide the report to the appraiser when the appraiser receives the assignment. The bill also requires creditors to give a copy of any energy report to a prospective borrower upon request at no cost. Operationally, this requires lenders to collect consent, store and transmit energy report files securely, and implement procedures to satisfy borrower portability requests.
Appraiser must consider energy characteristics and their market relevance
A qualified appraiser receiving an energy report must take its information into account and consider specific items: energy efficiency characteristics, renewable features, estimated energy savings, and relative consumption versus comparable homes. The appraiser must determine whether those characteristics are relevant to market value. The bill leaves the appraiser discretion on weight and valuation method but makes consideration mandatory when a report is provided.
Agency guidance, stakeholder advisory committee, and system changes
Heads of covered agencies must jointly issue guidance confirming acceptance of valuation approaches that show market response to energy features, set procedures for disclosures and report sharing, and explicitly not prescribe how appraisers must use the data. They must also form an advisory committee with specified stakeholder groups to advise implementation. Within two years of enactment agencies must require creditors to use origination and underwriting systems that can review and score appraisals consistent with the guidance—imposing concrete IT and workflow requirements on lenders.
Who and what the Act covers: agencies, loans, energy reports, and qualified appraisers
Key definitions: covered agencies are FHA, FHFA (as it exercises oversight of the enterprises), Ginnie Mae, USDA Rural Housing Service, and VA; covered loans are residential mortgage loans tied to those agencies; energy reports must document home energy features and estimate costs/savings and generation and may use HERS, DOE Home Energy Score, or other Secretary‑approved methods with QA; a qualified appraiser needs state licensure, demonstrated competence, and completion of the 7‑hour AQB‑approved continuing education course. These definitions determine reach and compliance responsibilities.
This bill is one of many.
Codify tracks hundreds of bills on Housing across all five countries.
Explore Housing in Codify Search →Who Benefits and Who Bears the Cost
Every bill creates winners and losers. Here's who stands to gain and who bears the cost.
Who Benefits
- Owners and buyers of energy‑efficient homes: The bill creates a formal pathway for energy upgrades and renewable installations to be considered in appraisals, increasing the chance that energy investments are reflected in market value and loan proceeds.
- Energy raters and certifiers (RESNET raters, Home Energy Score providers): Demand for standardized energy reports should rise if lenders and appraisers rely on these products, creating new revenue opportunities for raters and QA providers.
- GSEs and federal housing programs: Better incorporation of energy characteristics into valuations can improve collateral accuracy for loans they insure, guarantee, or buy, potentially reducing mispricing of energy‑related risk and improving risk models over time.
Who Bears the Cost
- Creditors and lenders (especially small originators): Lenders must update disclosures, obtain borrower consent, store and transmit reports, and adapt origination and underwriting systems within a two‑year window—requiring IT changes, staff training, and process redesign.
- Appraisers and appraisal management companies: Appraisers must complete AQB‑approved continuing education, increase competence in interpreting energy reports, and may face longer assignment times or more complex inspections; AMCs will need workflow and vendor management adjustments.
- Covered agencies and regulators: Agencies must jointly draft guidance, run an advisory committee, and oversee lender system requirements, creating administrative burdens that may not be paired with additional funding or staffing.
Key Issues
The Core Tension
The bill tries to reconcile two legitimate goals—making appraisals reflect real energy‑related value so energy upgrades pay off, and preserving appraisal independence and underwriting stability—but doing both creates trade‑offs: mandating consideration and system changes improves data flow and signal capture, yet leaves uncertain how to measure value consistently, imposes compliance costs, and risks uneven market adoption that could advantage some borrowers and regions over others.
The bill sets process and minimum quality standards but stops short of prescribing how appraisers must quantify energy savings into dollars of market value. That preserves professional judgment but raises implementation ambiguity: appraisers will need clear market evidence (paired sales, cost‑to‑value adjustments, or recognized income approaches) to consistently translate energy scores into value.
The two‑year systems deadline and the requirement for AQB‑approved coursework create concrete compliance steps, but appraisal industry capacity to certify large numbers of appraisers quickly is uncertain.
Practical questions about who pays for an energy report and when it is ordered remain unresolved by the text. The bill requires creditors to give borrowers a copy of a report at no cost if the lender has one, but it does not require creditors to obtain or pay for the initial report.
That leaves cost allocation to market practice—potentially creating unequal outcomes if only some sellers or buyers elect to commission reports. There is also a risk of adverse selection: buyers or owners with favorable reports may be more likely to share them, biasing the data available to appraisers and lenders.
Finally, the interaction with automated valuation models (AVMs), secondary market pricing, and fair lending oversight will demand careful guidance to avoid unintended discriminatory or inconsistent valuation outcomes.
Try it yourself.
Ask a question in plain English, or pick a topic below. Results in seconds.